Skip to main content

The Loss of Our Tranquil Certainties

The uproar over Roseanne Barr’s ugly comment about Valerie Jarrett is getting the attention it deserves. I’m only a small shell on a giant seashore but let me say I applaud ABC for their courageous decision to cancel Roseanne’s show.

It takes true integrity to put a successful company’s core values over a TV series that was producing multimillions of dollars of advertising. Whatever other motives the network may have had, they certainly proved they were willing to lose a highly profitable show in order to stand on the side of common decency and intolerance of racist comments from one of their most popular stars.

Let’s look at it once again. Roseanne Barr, responding to a comment about President Obama’s former advisor, Valerie Jarrett, tweeted: “muslim brotherhood and planet of the apes had a baby=vj.”

If you can find a way to defend that statement, I’m afraid you have crossed the boundaries of rational thought. Just a joke, you say? Everyone does it? Others have said worse? Twitter is where you can say anything you like? It’s freedom of speech, man!

No. None of that can account for a mean, defamatory, irresponsible comment about another person. Roseanne Barr had come back with huge popularity. Her show was the highest rated series on ABC. It was bringing the network gobs of cash. And with one crude, racist comment, it all crumbled to ashes. Creating loss of work for all the other cast members who were thrilled with the show’s success.

The comment highlights a common error in our day. We have lost all sense of personal dignity. We have diminished humanity to such a dismissive place that we now justify malicious comments, actions, and behavior as nothing to be bothered about.

The stain covers all of us.

Of course, we’ve all made crude comments, laughed at jokes that demean others, tolerated racism at work, and failed to defend people who were being hassled or bullied. And each time I have been in those situations and didn’t speak up I left feeling like a coward. And I was a coward.

We cannot casually accept comments like Roseanne Barr’s without losing some vital part of our humanity. It violates our own self-respect as well as the respect of others if we just dismiss that kind of callous jeering of another person.

In J.M. Coetzee’s award-winning novel, “Waiting for the Barbarians,” the main narrator, an unnamed civil servant, is repulsed by the brutality against the nomads taken prisoner by the Empire. After complying himself he finally can no longer do it. In disgust he says, “To the last we have learned nothing. In all of us, deep down, there seems to be something granite and unteachable. No one truly believes, despite the hysteria in the streets, that the world of tranquil certainties we were born into is about to be extinguished.”

There is a danger in our acceptance of cruel jokes, racist jesting, outright mean comments. It is the danger that the “tranquil certainties we were born into” may very well be extinguished.

It is the kind of courage demonstrated by the executives at ABC that enable those certainties to survive.

We all need that courage. We cannot dismiss or keep silent in the presence of human indignity. Our deepest values mean nothing if we do.

Well done, ABC.


© 2018 Timothy Moody

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

OPINION PAGE:

  OPINION PAGE © 2024 Timothy Moody The apparent assassination attempt against Donald Trump last Sunday afternoon at his Trump International Golf Club was foiled by the Secret Service. Details are still coming in about it, and it's not yet known why the suspect, Ryan Wesley Routh, 58, apparently wanted to shoot Trump. The botched attempt was amateurish in every way, just as the one in July was by a kid 150 yards from Trump.  Conspiracy theorists are having a field day.  The former President is, of all things, blaming these attempts on his life with what he called the “violent rhetoric” of President Biden and VP Harris. Of course, that is absurd, especially coming from Trump, who has consistently been guilty of that very thing since he became president in 2016 and even before.  His speeches, X posts, and comments on his Truth Social platform have been endlessly filled with threatening language and incitement to violence.  He suggested those protest...

A Losing Strategy

OPINION PAGE (c) 2024 Timothy Moody   The Republican strategy to mock and judge others has passed into some form of insatiable, all-devouring nastiness. It is so poisonous and contemptuous that it is now just evil.  Republican Governor of Arkansas, Sara Huckabee Sanders, suggested to a crowd of Trump supporters Tuesday night that Kamala Harris can't be humble because she doesn't have any children of her own.  When will Americans decide they don't want government leaders who are so arrogantly insensitive, as Sanders was, that they offend everyone?  This crude, villainous rhetoric transcends political partisanship. It’s evil, dangerous, and insulting.  The poet Ezra Pound’s brief lines are appropriate here, “Pull down your vanity, How mean your hates” To suggest that someone cannot be humble because they don't have children is not just a cheap political comment. It's an attack on a person’s humanity and worth.  And that is now, and has been fo...

Actions Make a Difference

“We make progress in society only if we stop cursing and complaining about its shortcomings and have the courage to do something about them.” ~ Dr. Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, Physician/Author Pictured here is Kikuko Shinjo, 89 years old, a survivor of the Hiroshima atomic bomb blast. As a 17-year old nursing student she helped nurse victims of the carnage back to health. Many of them died in her care. She says she holds no grudge against America and encourages interaction between the Japanese and Americans. She has devoted her life to peace, saying, “I want all the people around the world to be friends, and I want to make my country peaceful without fighting.” Today she makes colorful paper cranes and donates them to the Children’s Peace Monument at the Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park.